Nov 16

Choosing a Tech-Savvy Divorce Lawyer

Written by: Megan Dell

Share    

When I started practicing family law fifteen years ago, custody proof arrived on paper. It was a paper planner or wall calendar. It was a handwritten diary. It was greeting cards someone had saved.

To learn what happened in a marriage, I asked people. Then I reviewed what they had written down by hand.

But now clients come in with years of text messages or footage from a doorbell camera. Almost none of this digital evidence was created on purpose, but all of it can end up in front of a judge during divorce proceedings. Now, dealing with technology and divorce is an entirely distinct skillset.

Your case is mostly made of things you already wrote

Most people think evidence is something a lawyer must go find. In family court, most evidence already exists.

You created much of it. You wrote the messages. You set up the camera pointed at your own front door. You linked the accounts, devices, and shared calendars.

The spread of your personal information across so many platforms changes how your attorney approaches your case. Instead of relying mainly on your account of events, I focus on finding the records that already exist, and then selecting and presenting the parts that matter most for spousal support and developing your parenting plan.

What do text messages actually prove?

Phone and printed text message screenshots on a desk, evidence a tech-savvy divorce lawyer reviewsText messages are often some of the most persuasive evidence in family court because they capture how people actually communicate. Even a spouse who seems careful and reasonable in a deposition may have sent very different messages late at night, and those messages can reveal patterns that are hard to explain through testimony alone.

The challenge is volume. Modern marriages can generate thousands of texts, but only a small portion usually matters in court. The most useful messages tend to involve custody or finances—parenting schedules, school decisions, threats or harassment, admissions, spending, hidden assets, or other financial misconduct.

You usually don’t need to gather every message you’ve ever sent. You need the right ones: the messages that tie directly to the issues the court will consider. We can help you identify what matters, stay focused, and avoid costly mistakes.

Most homes have devices that keep a log

Almost every house has three or four things in it that keep a digital log or data trail of what happens there. They also keep logging while a case is pending.

Everything below works both ways. It can help you document your spouse’s conduct for evidence. It also reflects your daily life, which your spouse may be monitoring.

Can your spouse get the video from the doorbell camera?

A Ring doorbell logs who comes and goes and when. Smart thermostats can record when a house is occupied and when it’s empty.Doorbell camera on a front door, collecting evidence a tech-savvy divorce lawyer may review

In many marriages, one spouse handles the technology, and that spouse will set up everything using their login. When a couple separates and begins the legal process, whoever holds that login, account access, username/password, or admin rights might still be able to access the data. 

If the account is not yours, someone else can watch when you get home and who comes to the door, and you might not realize it at all. 

Smart speakers allow eavesdropping

An Alexa or Google Home keeps a history of what it was asked to do. It also stores an activity log with timestamps. It may keep short audio clips of the requests.

And if your spouse controls the device, then they can use it to listen in (regardless of whether it’s legal for them to do so).

Once you’ve decided to divorce, you have to consider: whose login is the speaker on, and can they listen in as I live my life?

What your car’s navigation system saved

A vehicle with OnStar or a comparable connected service keeps trip history and some location tracking. The manufacturer’s app often shows a current location to whoever’s account it’s linked to. 

As we saw with the Murdaugh trial, these built-in navigation services store recent destinations, and a car that pairs with a phone may also keep a copy of its contacts and call history long after the phone stops connecting.

A GPS tracker someone attached to the car on purpose is a separate issue. 

For at least the last decade, location tracking has been used to reduce the cost of proving adultery in divorce cases. If your car’s navigation system is connected to your spouse’s account and you’re asking for alimony, you should bet the system is being used to conduct surveillance.

What about the accounts you share?

Once you handle the hardware, what remains is what you built together, which can include shared logins or apps that combine your bank accounts.

You may also have shared calendars or use each other’s grocery store rewards card. (During my own separation, my husband received a text from Lowe’s when I ordered a new water heater.)

A lot of this is just uncomfortable and invasive, but some information is directly related to your family law matter because it affects money, marital assets, or financial disclosure. 

Changing every password or deleting can backfire

Once people understand how much of their personal information might be accessible to their estranged spouse, they want to shut them out immediately. 

Changing Passwords

A new password doesn’t do much if the reset codes still go to an email address or phone number your spouse controls. And if you think a phone or laptop has been compromised, monitored, or hacked, it may be safer to use a different device. 

Deleting May Hurt You

Deleting your accounts comes with an even bigger risk. Clearing old messages, trading in your phone, or deleting an app can erase evidence you may need later. 

Once you know litigation is likely, deleting information can have serious consequences. It may be treated as evidence spoliation, which can result in court sanctions.

Do Not Access Your Spouse’s Account

Your spouse’s accounts are a separate question. Knowing someone’s password is not the same thing as having permission to use it. Ask before you log in to anything that isn’t yours, including financial records, social media accounts, or cloud storage.

What does it take to get any of this in front of a judge?

Having the material and being able to use it are different problems. A party must show the item’s source and confirm it is unchanged. This may require obtaining it from the original source, not a phone. It may also require a subpoena to a third-party company. Such a company may have little incentive to respond promptly. It may also resist producing documents or authenticating business records.

Applying the Rules of Evidence is the part clients rarely anticipate. It’s the difference between a case where the evidence works and one where everybody knows what happened but nobody can prove it in court.

You shouldn’t pay to have every message read

Nobody can review every marital message within a sensible case budget. Someone must decide early, and intentionally, what’s worth reviewing and what’s not.

That decision is a skill. Done well, it costs a fraction of what a full review would and still finds the material that matters. Done badly, you pay for page after page of nothing, or you miss the one exchange that would have moved the judge, affected custody, or changed a settlement.

What to ask to hire a tech-savvy divorce lawyer

One of the first substantive steps a tech-savvy lawyer takes is to inventory what accounts are still connected. The lawyer then tells you, in order, what to shut down and what to leave in place. Closing the wrong account at the wrong time can create a different problem. 

Three questions worth asking in a consultation:

  1. What in my case is likely to be digital evidence (texts, emails, social media), and what expires first?
  2. What of mine can the other side still see online, and what should I preserve or stop doing right now to protect my case?
  3. How do you handle a case with years of messages, chats, and phone records without charging me to review all of them?

You’re not testing whether the divorce attorney can name the apps, platforms, or devices. You’re finding out how often they’ve handled digital evidence before you walked in.

I have watched divorce evidence shift from paper to phones almost completely. The law and the divorce process have not kept pace with that change.

If any of this is part of your case – divorce, child custody, child support, or property division – reach out to us at Dell Family Law to schedule a consultation. And once you’ve scheduled a consultation, ask us for a copy of our “Technology Checklist During Divorce.”

Get started hiring a divorce lawyer at Dell Family Law